Skip to main content

This study 40 years ago could have reshaped the American diet. But it was never fully published.

It was one of the largest, most rigorous experiments ever conducted on an important diet question: How do fatty foods affect our health? Yet it took more than 40 years  — that is, until today —  for a clear picture of the results to reach the public.

The fuller results appeared Tuesday in BMJ, a medical journal, featuring some never-before-published data. Collectively, the fuller results undermine the conventional wisdom regarding dietary fat that has persisted for decades and is still enshrined in influential publications such as the U.S. government’s Dietary Guidelines for Americans.  But the long-belated saga of the Minnesota Coronary Experiment may also make a broader point about how science gets done: it suggests just how difficult it can be for new evidence  to see the light of day when it contradicts widely held theories.

The story begins in the late 1960s and early ’70s, when researchers in Minnesota engaged thousands of institutionalized mental patients to compare the effects of two diets.  One group of patients was fed a diet intended to lower blood cholesterol and reduce heart disease. It contained less saturated fat, less cholesterol and more vegetable oil. The other group was fed a more typical American diet.

Just as researchers expected, the special diet reduced blood cholesterol in patients. And while the special diet didn’t seem to have any effect on heart disease, researchers said they suspected that a benefit would have appeared if the experiment had gone on longer.

There was “a favorable trend,” they wrote, for younger patients.

Today, the principles of that special diet — less saturated fat, more vegetable oils — are recommended by the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, the government’s official diet advice book. Yet the fuller accounting of the Minnesota data indicates that the advice is, at best, unsupported by the massive trial. In fact, it appears to show just the opposite:  Patients who lowered their cholesterol, presumably because of the special diet, actually suffered more heart-related deaths than those who did not.

The higher rate of mortality for patients on the special diet was most apparent among patients older than 64.

The new researchers, led by investigators from the National Institutes of Health and the University of North Carolina, conclude that the absence of the data over the past 40 years or so may have led to a misunderstanding of this key dietary issue.

“Incomplete publication has contributed to the overestimation of benefits and underestimation of potential risks” of the special diet, they wrote.

“Had this research been published 40 years ago, it might have changed the trajectory of diet-heart research and recommendations” said Daisy Zamora, a researcher at UNC and a lead author of the study.

The new research drew quick criticism, however, especially from experts who have been prominent in the campaign against saturated fats.

“The bottom line is that this report adds no useful new information and is irrelevant to current dietary recommendations that emphasize replacing saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat,” Walter Willett, chair of the nutrition department at Harvard University, said in a blog post from the school. “Many lines of evidence support this conclusion.”

He characterized the new analysis of the old experiment as “an interesting historical footnote.”

***

Article credited: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/04/12/this-study-40-years-ago-could-have-reshaped-the-american-diet-but-it-was-never-fully-published/

You Might Also Enjoy...

When to Choose Botox® AND Fillers

When to Choose Botox® AND Fillers

You’ve seen the ads and listened to your favorite social media influencers but still don’t know when to decide between Botox® and dermal fillers and when to get both Botox AND fillers. Here’s how to choose.

How to Prepare for Hemorrhoid Surgery

Hemorrhoids — they can itch, hurt, bleed, and make it nearly impossible to focus on anything else. Your upcoming hemorrhoid surgery will solve all of that, but you can give your bottom a better chance at success if you prepare well. Here’s how.

How to Care for Your Skin After Laser Hair Removal

Shaving, waxing, and tweezing are painful, time-consuming, and costly. Switch to laser hair removal for long-lasting, painless, and cost-effective results. Here are some aftercare tips to ensure you stay smooth and comfortable.
5 Factors That Make Heartburn Worse

5 Factors That Make Heartburn Worse

You always keep a bottle of antacids nearby, but you still can’t get rid of your recurring heartburn. Chances are, you’re doing one of these things that bring on heartburn or make it worse.
Recovering From Gallbladder Surgery: What to Expect

Recovering From Gallbladder Surgery: What to Expect

When you’re scheduled for gallbladder surgery, you’re focused on how your life will improve after the procedure. Here’s what you need to know about your recovery and how to get from surgery to success smoothly.
Am I a Good Candidate for the LINX™ Procedure?

Am I a Good Candidate for the LINX™ Procedure?

When your esophagus weakens, you get severe acid reflux, and no amount of antacids can help — but LINX™ can. It stands in for your failing esophagus permanently. Find out here if the LINX procedure is right for you, and you’re right for LINX.